Search our Restaurants.

Nickel Inn

12045 Bone Run Rd
Frewsburg, NY
(716) 354-5011

See Map | See more restaurants in Frewsburg
4.6 stars 4.6 stars 
 based on 7 ratings
Tags: No tags yet. [Add/Edit Tags]

More Restaurants in Frewsburg


[Add a Review]
Rating:  5.0 stars
Still going strong.
April 4, 2012 by Anonymous Eater

The Nichol Inn and me have a long romantic history. My first dinner date with my husband and many other great celebrations in the last 21 years. The food is always exceptional and the atmosphere is always perfect whether your alone with your loved one or with a group of dear freinds and family. As long as they continue to do what they do we will continue to go there. My favorite restaurant by far. Love love love it.
Rating:  5.0 stars
Great memories.
October 25, 2010 by Anonymous Eater

The Nickle was the first place my husband every took me to dinner. It was in October and the place was decorated so beautifully for the fall season. In the past 19 years we have returned many times and every time it is a wonderful experience with delicious food and wonderful atmosphere. Keep up the good work.
Rating:  4.0 stars
April 17, 2010 by Anonymous Eater

Great Food
Good Service
Beautiful Place
Friendly Staff
Great Atomsphere
Rating:  5.0 stars
Nickle Lover
February 13, 2010 by Andre

I've been here a thousand times and it's still the best! I recommend to all. They have the best prime rib around hands down.
Rating:  4.0 stars
Once Upon a Time
January 12, 2010 by Shells323

I went there as a kid when the family would decide to go out to dinner for a rare occasion. I always remembered the hummingbird feeders hanging around the outside. And I ALWAYS got the chicken fingers when we went there. I haven't been there in YEARS as I live in Arizona now, but it will always be a place I remember well from my childhood.
Rating:  4.0 stars
Great food, great atmosphere
July 25, 2009 by Steve Anderson

I haven't been to the Nickel Inn in quite a long time, but I remember going there often as a kid with my family. I always thought the "buffalo" nickel on the doors was very cool. The food was great, as was the lodge style atmosphere. Definitely recommended if you're in the Jamestown area. Its a bit of drive from Jamestown, but its worth it.
Rating:  5.0 stars
Best Jamestown New York Resturant
September 25, 2008 by Anonymous Eater

Great food, wonderful atmosphere,just minutes from jamestown new york, best dinning in the jamestown area...
Three Stars
Mark Polaski
William Braodhead Mansion
Jamestown, New York 14701

Need your car repaired? Visit for auto repair shops in Frewsburg.


Is there something incorrect or inappropriate on this page? Let us know and we'll take care of it.